dairy

/ blog / By

Creamy or Cultured: Breaking Down Dairy            

Dairy foods have been around for 8,000 – 9,000 years, when humans domesticated animals like goats, sheep and cattle. Milk consumption and the lack of refrigeration during that time eventually led to the discovery of fermented products like yogurt and cheese. Despite its presence for millennia, few food groups today spark as much debate as dairy.  This post concentrates mostly on cow’s milk with a brief mention of goat and sheep dairy.

 

The Benefits of Dairy

 
1. Dense and Efficient
  • Milk, yogurt and cheese contain all essential amino acids, making them high-quality, complete proteins.
  • Great for muscle maintenance, immune function and satiety.
2. Rich in Nutrients
  • One of the richest sources of dietary calcium, essential for bone and tooth health, nerve transmission and muscle contraction.
  • Supplies vitamin D (frequently fortified), phosphorus, potassium and vitamin B12.
  • Can improve bone density and may help reduce the risk of osteoporosis later in life.
3. Probiotics
  • Fermented versions like yogurt, kefir and certain cheeses contain beneficial bacteria that can support gut health.
  • Probiotics can improve lactose digestion and potentially influence inflammation and immune responses.
4. Brain and Heart Health
  • Minerals in dairy can help to maintain healthy blood pressure, lowering the risk of cardiovascular disease and stroke.
  • Protein, vitamins and nutrients like choline are vital for brain development and cognition, especially in children.
5. Sleep Aid
  • Drinking warm milk can promote relaxation and having a full tummy can be a comforting feeling.
  • More scientifically, tryptophan, calcium and magnesium can affect the production of melatonin, improving the initiation of sleep.

 

The Controversies

 

1. Cause of Inflammation?
  • There is a suggestion that dairy proteins (casein and whey) may trigger symptoms in people with autoimmune diseases. However, dairy is not likely inflammatory for most people.
  • Fermented dairy may even have anti-inflammatory effects.
  • Highly processed products like sweetened yogurts, ultra-processed cheeses and dairy based desserts contain excess sugar, sodium and additives that may contribute to inflammation.
2. Hormones and Growth Factors
  • Milk naturally contains hormones and stimulates insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1). IGF-1 may promote uncontrolled cell growth, which may contribute to an increased risk of certain cancers.
  • Concerns include an increased risk of acne with skim milk and possible effects on hormone-sensitive conditions like polycystic ovary syndrome.
  • Hormone levels in milk are low, but chronic exposure and individual sensitivity continue to be debated as a negative effect of consumption of milk products.
3. Dairy Fat and Heart Disease
  • Older guidelines warned against saturated fat. Newer research suggests full-fat dairy may be protective against heart disease.
  • Butter remains more consistently linked to increased LDL cholesterol.
4. Bone Health Paradox
  • High dairy intake does not consistently reduce fracture risk.
  • Countries with high dairy consumption still have high osteoporosis rates.
  • Bone health depends on many factors, not just calcium.
5. Cancer Risk
  • May lower colorectal cancer risk but increase risk of prostate cancer when consumed in large amounts.
  • Breast cancer findings are inconsistent.
6. Lactose Intolerance
  • A significant portion of the global population is affected by lactose intolerance, which is the lack of an enzyme that breaks down milk sugar (lactose).
  • Bloating, gas and diarrhea are common when lactose-containing foods are consumed. However, it is not a life-threatening allergy.
  • Lactose-free or fermented options are often better tolerated.
7. Milk Protein Sensitivity
  • Involves a sensitivity to casein or whey, causing allergy symptoms like hives, breathing problems or even anaphylaxis.
  • More common in children but adults report inflammatory or gastrointestinal symptoms linked to dairy.
8. Beyond Nutrition
  • Environmental and ethical considerations influence dairy’s role, though these topics extend beyond nutrition. 
  • Issues include greenhouse gas emissions, water and land use as well as animal welfare concerns.

 

Breaking it Down

Type of Dairy
Pros
Cons

 Milk

Whole milk:

  • Contains fat-soluble vitamins (K2, A, D, E)
  • More satisfying than low-fat milk
  • Natural source of conjugated linoleic acid (an omega-6 fatty acid), which has anti-inflammatory effects when consumed in food (not supplements)

Skim milk:

  • High in protein and calcium with fewer calories than whole milk
  • Often fortified with vitamin D

Skim milk is less filling

Skim milk has lower absorption of fat-soluble vitamins

Yogurt

Contains live probiotics that support gut health and immune regulation

May reduce inflammation and improve insulin sensitivity

Easier to digest due to partial lactose breakdown

Greek yogurt has higher protein

Take care to choose unsweetened varieties

Cheese

Aged cheeses (cheddar, parmesan, gouda) 

  • Very low lactose
  • High in protein
  • Rich in calcium, phosphorous and vitamin K2

Soft and Fresh Cheeses (ricotta, cottage cheese, mozzarella)

  • High in whey protein, which supports muscle repair
  • Lower fat options available
  • Good calcium source

Soft cheeses have higher lactose than aged cheeses

Kefir

More probiotic diversity than yogurt

Supports gut barrier integrity and may help reduce systemic inflammation

Often tolerated by lactose-sensitive individuals

Contains naturally occurring, low levels of alcohol as a byproduct of the fermentation process
Butter and Cream

Butter

  • Rich in butyrate, a fatty acid that supports gut and colon health
  • Contains vitamin A and K2
  • Has anti-inflammatory potential when used in moderation

Heavy Cream

  • Minimal lactose
  • Helps with satiety
  • Useful for blood sugar control when replacing refined carbs
Calorie dense

 

Other Dairy Products

Whey Protein
  • Supports muscle maintenance and immune function
  • Rich in leucine, which is important for muscle synthesis
  • May help reduce inflammation post-exercise
Goat and Sheep Dairy
  • Contain smaller fat globules than cow dairy, which leads to easier digestion
  • Sheep milk has higher protein, calcium, vitamins and minerals and is often creamier and richer
  • Goat and sheep milk contain a different protein structure than cow’s milk and is therefore more easily digested
  • Contain more calories and fats, but are rich in good, unsaturated fats

 

How to Cook with Dairy

  • Choose minimally processed forms: plain milk, yogurt, kefir and traditional cheeses
  • Use gentle heat: high heat can denature proteins and cause separation. For sauces, use low to medium heat and add dairy toward the end of cooking
  • Pair with fiber-rich foods: combining dairy with vegetables, legumes and whole grains will slow digestion and improve blood sugar control 
  • Favor fermentation: yogurt-based marinades, kefir smoothies or cultured butter sauces have digestive benefits 

Making yogurt sauces, ricotta-based fillings or vegetable dishes with added cheese allows dairy to add flavor and nutrient absorption without overpowering the dish.

 

Storage and Safety

Always discard dairy with changes in texture, visible mold (unless it’s a mold-ripened cheese) or an unusual smell.

  1. Milk and Cream

Should be stored in the coldest part of the refrigerator (not the door) and tightly sealed to prevent odor absorption.

  1. Yogurt and Kefir

Last longer when unopened and should be consumed within a few days once opened.

  1. Hard Cheeses

Wrap in breathable paper or waxed paper, then cover loosely to prevent moisture buildup.

  1. Soft Cheeses

Require airtight containers and close attention to expiration dates. 

 

The Bottom Line

  • Dairy can provide valuable nutrients and support gut health.
  • It’s important for an individual to be aware of how their body reacts to dairy.
  • When consumed correctly, dairy can absolutely earn its place at the table.